5 Numbers Every Agent Should Track at Midyear

Tom Toole shares the five numbers real estate agents should track this month to see exactly where their business is breaking down.
5-Numbers-Every-Agent-Should-Track-at-Midyear_Tom-Toole_BAM-featured-image
5-Numbers-Every-Agent-Should-Track-at-Midyear_Tom-Toole_BAM-featured-image
BAM BBQ 2026

If you're still treating AI like a search engine, this is for you. BAM BBQ is two and a half hours of real instruction on AI for real estate, from conversations to content to systems. It’s free, virtual, and loaded with plays you can run the same week. Save your spot →

Six smiling real estate agents stand against orange, black, and red panels with a bold headline about learning AI now and BAMx/realtor logos in the band at the bottom.
FREE VIRTUAL EVENT
BAM BBQ 2026

If you're still treating AI like a search engine, this is for you. BAM BBQ is two and a half hours of real instruction on AI for real estate, from conversations to content to systems. It’s free, virtual, and loaded with plays you can run the same week. Save your spot →

You’re halfway through the year. If total sales is the only number you’re using to judge how you’re doing, you’re missing the real story.

Sales are a lag indicator. They tell you what already happened. They don’t tell you what to fix right now, before the second half plays out.

I track five numbers in my own business, and they’re the same five I’d tell you to track today. Each one points to a different problem in your pipeline, and each one has a fix.

Just because you’re down at halftime doesn’t mean the game is over.

youtube placeholder image

 

5 Numbers To Track At The Midyear Mark

Pull out the business plan you built in the fourth quarter of last year. Blow the dust off it and look at what daily activities you actually committed to.

I know my numbers because I track them in real time. I’m making around 100 dials a day to hit 15 conversations. From those conversations, I want at least one appointment with someone who wants to sell their home. I expect 70% of those appointments to show up, and 70% of the ones that show to sign a contract.

Those are my numbers, and they’re predictable because I’ve tracked them long enough to know what to expect. Most agents watching this don’t have that data yet, and that’s the reality in this business.

Here are the five numbers behind that plan:

  1. Outbound attempts, meaning dials and texts
  2. Conversations
  3. Appointments set
  4. Appointments met
  5. Clients signed

Each one tells you something different about where your funnel is breaking down.

#1: Your Outbound Attempts Show Your Effort

The number of dials and outbound attempts is your sweat equity. It’s the simplest number on this list because it just measures how much work you’re actually putting in.

If you’re opening your CRM and making two or three outreach attempts a day, you can work harder than that. If you’re already at 50 or more, that’s a strong base to build from.

Texts and emails create reactions, but the phone call is the real work. The ratios back this up. You should expect roughly four to six dials for every one conversation you get on the phone.

If your dial count is low, make more calls.

#2: Your Conversations Show Your Prospecting

Conversations are number two, and they tell a different story than dials do. I’ve seen agents dial just to dial, calling random neighborhoods and burning through 20 or 30 calls just to get one person on the phone.

If that’s happening to you, you’re not working the right list. You should be landing a real conversation every four to six outbound attempts. If you’re nowhere close to that ratio, the problem isn’t your effort. It’s your list.

Some agents will tell you they’re texters instead of callers. I don’t buy it. The data on phone calls is documented, and it works. If you’re not having 15 conversations a day, you’re not giving yourself a real shot at your goals.

Dials and conversations together show you two things: your effort, and how well you’ve planned who you’re actually prospecting.

#3: Your Appointments Set Show Your Scripts

Appointments set is where a lot of agents hit their first real wall. Compare how many people you’re talking to against how many appointments you’re actually setting, and look at the ratio.

You want to be setting an appointment somewhere between every 10 to 15 conversations. If you’re nowhere near that, you’ve got a scripting problem, not an effort problem.

That might mean your openers aren’t landing. It might mean you’re not asking the right questions once you’re on the phone. Either way, it’s a skill you build through repetition, not something you fix by making more calls.

If you’re not practicing your scripts on your own time, you’re practicing on your clients instead, and that’s a rough way to build a track record. Role play them until they’re second nature. 

If your ratio is closer to 25 or 30 conversations per appointment, that’s your sign to slow down and rebuild your script before you make another call. If you want a faster way to build and rehearse scripts that actually convert, the BAMx AI Script Advisor is built for exactly this.

BAMx-AI-Script-Advisor-CTA-image

Sign up for a 7-day free trial at the VIP level to get access. 

#4: Your Appointments Met Show Your Pre-Appointment Process

Setting an appointment and having someone actually show up are two different numbers. If you’re booking appointments but people aren’t meeting with you, the problem lives in your pre-appointment process.

Think about what you’re doing to build importance around that appointment before it happens. A few ways to do that:

  • Send a pre-appointment email
  • Send a short video introducing yourself
  • Send a resume or track record ahead of the meeting
  • Send a calendar invite with a text reminder, which most CRMs like Follow Up Boss already build in

Your hairdresser sends you a text reminder. So does your dry cleaner and your dentist. There’s no reason real estate should be any different.

I run a documented pre-appointment process that gets me to a 70%+ sign rate, and it’s built from being in the trenches, not from theory. 

If your show rate is under 50%, that process is the first place to look.

#5: Your Clients Signed Show Your Appointment Itself

The last number is clients signed. If you’re meeting 10 people and not signing any of them, whether that’s a buyer agency agreement or a listing contract, the problem is the appointment itself.

Ask yourself a few honest questions. Do you have an appointment that delivers a predictable result, or are you winging it every time? Do you have the right supporting documentation? Are you asking questions and taking a consultative approach, or are you doing most of the talking?

On a seller appointment, you want to cover:

  • How to get the right emotional reaction to the home
  • How to get the right exposure, both online and offline
  • How to position the home to be next to sell on pricing

On a buyer appointment, you want to cover:

  • The client’s actual goals, first and foremost
  • How the financing process works, if they need it
  • How the purchase process works, if they need it
  • The current state of the market

What kills appointments fastest is making the whole conversation about you. If you’re leaning on a pitch that sounds like this, you’re already losing the room:

“We’re the number one team or we do this or we do that or I sell lots of homes. You should work with me, me, me, me, me.”

Make it about the consumer, not about you, and your sign rate will follow.

What To Do With These Numbers This Week

Have a real meeting with yourself and get honest about where your funnel is breaking down. If you’re already ahead of pace, keep doing what you’re doing. 

If you’re behind, start with your sweat equity. That’s dials and conversations. Check your prep before you start prospecting and doing lead follow-up.

  • If appointments aren’t getting set, the issue is your scripts. 
  • If they’re not showing up, it’s your pre-appointment process. 
  • If they’re not signing, it’s the appointment itself.

The number that’s breaking down tells you exactly where to spend your time for the rest of the year.

Download the printable PDF with all 27 lines:

Sign Up for the BAM Newsletter

For daily real estate news, business and marketing.

About the Author

Tom and his team catapulted to the #1 ranked team in Pennsylvania, a title held since 2018. Known for strategic business operations, Tom shares sales techniques and business tactics as a sought-after speaker throughout the United States. He also hosts Toole Time, Tom’s Take, and Agent Hacks and is a moderator for the 5AM Call.

Share:

Related Posts

Recent Articles

Upcoming Events

Virtual Event
Virtual
Webinar
Virtual

Related Posts