Why Your Google Reviews Keep Disappearing (and How to Fix It)

Frustrated by disappearing Google reviews? Discover why it happens and how to prevent it.
Why Your Google Reviews Keep Disappearing (and How to Fix It)
Why Your Google Reviews Keep Disappearing (and How to Fix It)
TEAM LEADERS: SCALE PAST $100M

Join Byron Lazine, Tom Toole, Lisa Chinatti, George Laughton, Amy Stockberger, Gino Blefari, Luke Acree, and top team leaders at BAM Camp: Team Leaders, September 22–23 in Scottsdale. This intimate, two-day workshop is built to help you scale your team, increase profit, strengthen leadership, and leave with a clear 90-day action plan. Get your ticket before it sells out →

Promo banner for BAM CAMP Team Leaders in Scottsdale, AZ, September 22–23, with a collage of ten speakers on a black background and the text BAMCAMP.LIVE.
TEAM LEADERS: SCALE PAST $100M

Join Byron Lazine, Tom Toole, Lisa Chinatti, George Laughton, Amy Stockberger, Gino Blefari, Luke Acree, and top team leaders at BAM Camp: Team Leaders, September 22–23 in Scottsdale. This intimate, two-day workshop is built to help you scale your team, increase profit, strengthen leadership, and leave with a clear 90-day action plan. Get your ticket before it sells out →

Let me tell you a story about reviews that changed everything for me. It was March 2020, right when Covid hit hard. We’d just gotten a Saint Bernard puppy, and everyone was still in that “don’t go into each other’s houses” phase.

My Dad, bless his heart, is a total boomer. He came over to see my puppy and saw all the Amazon boxes in front of my house. “Son,” he said, “you are shopping too much.” 

I tried to explain, “Dad, this is how everyone shops now, and all the stores are about to be closed.” 

He just shook his head, “I like to see and touch things before I buy them.” 

I couldn’t resist teasing him, “Well, you also still have an AOL email address…so….”

Fast forward a month, and I’m at his place with my dog. What do I see? A bunch of Amazon boxes. My dad sheepishly admitted, “Oh yeah, it’s great. I can just see the review count and not even think. I just click purchase.”

That’s when it hit me like a ton of bricks. The average age of a home seller is 60, and they’re all really leaning into review shopping for the first time. Our team HAD to win in this space. This realization has been our biggest driver for growth, and it’s why we’ll close nearly $200 million in volume this year.

Why Google Reviews Disappear

But here’s the thing – maintaining those crucial Google reviews isn’t always smooth sailing. Our team at Fox Homes has over 1,706 reviews, but we still get panicked messages from our agents: “Help! My client’s review is visible on their end, but it’s not showing up on our Google Business Profile!” 

Sound familiar?

Here’s what’s happening: Google’s review filter is getting stricter. It’s especially picky when clients leave reviews from out of state or while on vacation. Google flags this as potentially fake activity.

But don’t worry, I’ve got a trick that almost guarantees your reviews will stick around. 

How to Ensure Google Reviews are Posted

Have your clients add a photo (or video) to their review—a snap of the house they bought or sold, or even better, a happy closing photo. I’ve yet to see a review with a photo removed by Google.

This strategy has a bonus effect: When potential clients are scrolling through your reviews, which do you think will catch their eye? Plain text reviews, or a bunch of smiling faces in front of “SOLD” signs? 

Or better yet, a video of your clients popping the celebratory champagne. Plus, Google often pushes these photo reviews to the top. It’s a win-win!

Dustin Fox
For camera-shy clients, use a front exterior shot from the walk-through or your property listing video. Pro tip: Rename the file to something like “Best Realtor in Fairfax” for extra SEO impact.

How to Recover Google Reviews

Even with these tricks, sometimes reviews still disappear. But don’t panic! Here’s a step-by-step guide to recover them:

  1. Go to Google Business Profile Help.
  2. Log in with your GBP-associated Google account.
  3. When asked what you need help with, type “Missing reviews.”
4. Click through until you hit “Contact options,” then hit “Email.”
5. Fill out the form that pops up. Include screenshots of the missing review in a Google Doc and link it in the “Describe your issue” section.
Google usually responds in 5-7 business days. They don’t always reinstate every review, but it’s worth trying.

Remember, persistence is key in this review game. Keep encouraging those photo reviews, and don’t be afraid to fight for the ones that slip through the cracks. With these strategies, you’ll master the art of Google Reviews in no time.

Want more insights like these? Check out my book, Six Weeks to Real Estate Success available on Amazon. It’s packed with tips to help you thrive in today’s real estate market.

Now, let’s go get those reviews and grow your business!

Download the printable PDF with all 27 lines:

Sign Up for the BAM Newsletter

For daily real estate news, business and marketing.

About the Author

Dustin Fox, co-founder of the Fox Homes Team with his wife Devon, has revolutionized real estate advertising through mastery of Facebook, Instagram, Google PPC, YouTube Ads, and SEO. Author of ”Six Weeks to Real Estate Success,” Dustin has propelled the team to over $400 million in sales in just three years, redefining industry standards for digital marketing excellence.

Share:

Related Posts

Man in a black BAM shirt looks at his phone, with a collage of marketing thumbnails on a black background.
Agent Marketing

Five Things To Do While Bored At Your Open

Get five actionable real estate plays for agents, including Labor Day conversation starters, a 2026 social media blueprint, BAM’s 100K follower strategy, community resources, and the housing market realities that matter right now.

Read More »

Recent Articles

Upcoming Events

Masterclass
In-Person
Masterclass
In-Person
Webinar
Virtual

Related Posts