The Exact Questions to Ask Buyers After Every Showing

I watch agents ignore feedback requests constantly, and it’s costing them more than they realize. Getting feedback on a listing is already a pain for listing agents. 

What most agents don’t realize is that the problem usually starts earlier, on the buyer side.

If you’re not asking your buyer clients for feedback the second a showing wraps up, you might be spinning your wheels without even knowing it.

Click here to accept Marketing cookies and load this content

3 Reasons to Treat Showing Feedback as Part of the Job

There are three reasons agents should treat feedback as part of the job:

1. It makes you sharper as a buyer’s agent, because you stop showing homes your clients have no interest in.
2. It makes conversations with sellers easier, because karma runs both ways in this business.
3. It keeps your inbox from clogging up with feedback requests you’re too busy avoiding to answer.

Let’s start where I see agents leave the most value on the table: the buyer side.

Why Buyer Feedback Is the Biggest Gap I See

A lot of agents show homes and open doors, then move on. Not asking what your buyer thought after a showing means you’re giving up information that would make you better at your job. 

Without it, you risk showing people homes they have zero interest in, which annoys buyers (by wasting their time) and makes them feel unheard. 

Here’s the sequence I run after every showing:

1. Ask them directly what they thought (and ask with a smile).
2. Have them rate the home on a 1 to 10 scale, with one rule: they can’t pick seven.
3. Ask why they landed on that number.
4. If the answer lands on a five or six, dig deeper.

Here’s exactly what that sounds like:

“What did you think? Can you rate the home one to 10, and you can’t pick seven. What made it that number?”

Seven is the number everyone defaults to, so taking it off the table forces a real answer. Here’s how I read the number once it comes back:

“Anything below a seven, I’m not going to really want to get you into moving forward. And if it’s above a seven, hey, this is offer territory. We may want to think about how we move ahead on this property.”

When the score comes in low, at a five or a six, I ask a follow-up:

“What made that home a five or a six? What would it have to have to be above seven?”

Asking why forces a real conversation, and that conversation teaches your clients about the market every time they walk through a home. 

Touring homes has value on its own. Feedback is what turns that value into sharper decisions the next time you go out.

If you’re logging this in your CRM (and you should be) you can pull it up weeks later when a similar listing comes on the market:

“You rated a home just like this at a five. I know you said you want to go see it. We may want to avoid this one.”

This kind of callback saves your buyer time and keeps you looking like you’re paying attention, because you are.

Feedback Runs Both Ways: The Seller Side Needs It Too

If you’re a buyer’s agent and make a habit of passing on this feedback to the listing agent, a quick note is often all it takes:

“We thought the home was priced high. They didn’t like it because of X, Y, and Z.”

Karma is real in this business. Agents who don’t give feedback usually don’t get it back when they have a listing of their own. 

As a listing agent, I can tell you sellers want to hear feedback in real time, not weeks later. 

Data only tells you so much on the listing side. You can study what sold and what’s pending, and none of that tells you exactly how buyers will react once your specific home hits the market. 

Feedback from actual showings, paired with what you’re seeing in the trends, is what gives you a real conversation to have with your seller if a price adjustment is on the table.

The Professional Habit That Keeps Your Pipeline Moving

Giving feedback consistently also keeps your own inbox clear. Agents who ignore feedback requests after every showing are usually the same agents drowning in unanswered ones later. 

Someone let you into their home. Telling them how the showing went is the least you owe them.

Giving and accepting feedback is one of the most basic professional habits in this business. I take feedback constantly, and it’s one of the core values on our team.

If you’re skipping this step in the field, you’re probably hurting yourself on both ends: fewer conversions on the buyer side, and shakier pricing conversations once you’re the one holding the listing. 

Start treating feedback as part of the job, and run these questions on your very next showing.