3 Tips to Create CTAs that Convert

Haley Ingram breaks down three tips for creating CTAs that convert Instagram followers into email subscribers.
Person's hands hold a smartphone showing a grid view of video posts (reels) on a social media app against a beige background.
Person's hands hold a smartphone showing a grid view of video posts (reels) on a social media app against a beige background.
BAM BBQ 2026

If you're still treating AI like a search engine, this is for you. BAM BBQ is two and a half hours of real instruction on AI for real estate, from conversations to content to systems. It’s free, virtual, and loaded with plays you can run the same week. Save your spot →

Six smiling real estate agents stand against orange, black, and red panels with a bold headline about learning AI now and BAMx/realtor logos in the band at the bottom.
FREE VIRTUAL EVENT
BAM BBQ 2026

If you're still treating AI like a search engine, this is for you. BAM BBQ is two and a half hours of real instruction on AI for real estate, from conversations to content to systems. It’s free, virtual, and loaded with plays you can run the same week. Save your spot →

You know how powerful Instagram can be for your real estate business.

But, let me remind you of one very important detail—you do not own your Instagram follower list. So, it’s important to invite your followers over to your party in the email list! 

There are several ways to build an email list, but today, I’m going to focus on creating a call to action (CTA) that help you convert your IG followers into email list subscribers. 

 Keep reading for three simple tips to get more real estate leads online by building an email list your audience is anxiously waiting for.

#1—Don’t be boring with your incentive

Offering an incentive is a great way to draw potential subscribers to your email list. But it has to be something your audience actually wants.

Incentives can come in many forms, including:

  • Exclusive access to a new listing
  • Partner with local contractors or businesses for discounts on home improvement projects
  • A free guide or resource for home buyers or sellers

If you opt for a free guide, think of something valuable that your audience can’t find with a simple Google search. For example, a local holiday guide with all of the special events and shopping in your city for the holidays. If you partner with local businesses, you can even include some discount codes for their products or services. 

#2—Don’t keep it a secret

Once you have a valuable incentive for your audience, make sure you let everyone know about it!

Create posts surrounding the topic of the incentive to create curiosity and encourage your audience to sign up for them. 

For example, if your incentive is a New Construction Guide, create content about new construction projects in your market or highlight the homes of local builders. Then, remind your audience to grab your download through the link in your bio at the end of your post.

#3—Create valuable emails that your audience anxiously waits for

Once you have an email list, it’s important to ensure you continuously provide value through your emails. In our Coffee & Contracts email newsletters, we knew we wanted to add something valuable that our audience looks forward to receiving each week. So, we provide three Reel ideas or trending audios that agents can use every week (plus a ton of great marketing tips and tricks).

What’s something of value you can add to your emails each week? You could provide local events happening in your market each week, market updates, restaurant specials, etc. If you’re stuck for ideas, you can also create a poll to find out what your audience wants more of. Then, let your audience know what they’ll be receiving and how often. 

If you’re struggling with social media content and marketing for your business, click here to join the Coffee & Contracts community. And act fast—we’ll be closing membership on June 30th for the rest of the summer!

Download the printable PDF with all 27 lines:

Sign Up for the BAM Newsletter

For daily real estate news, business and marketing.

About the Author

Haley Ingram is the creator behind Coffee & Contracts. As a recent grad leading up to the launch, she was getting all her real estate leads from Instagram. She soon found her best hours go towards helping other agents with social media marketing. Today, this thriving community exists to help agents grow online through the power of social media.

Share:

Related Posts

Recent Articles

Upcoming Events

Virtual Event
Virtual
Webinar
Virtual

Related Posts